Professional and Career Topics

 View Only
  • 1.  Converting Lessons Learned into Lessons Shared

    Posted 09-16-2025 10:21 AM

    Something that I've been thinking about lately is how to effectively spread knowledge from "lessons learned" throughout a company or department. When you have 100+ people, an email about each one eventually becomes ignored background noise. At the same time, it is a waste for each person to have to individually learn the lessons through personal experience. 

    A recent example is a change in a local design criteria that requires using a more expensive material than is typically called out, but only in specific locations/cases. (This requirement is buried in an obscure location within a document we typically don't need to reference in the scope of our designs.) When one engineer asked around about it, several others had been "bit" by it on a project previously, but that information stopped with them.

    When people were asked in the past, though, to share any "lessons learned" that we could add to a group lunch and learn, very few people could think of any. It's difficult to recall random lessons learned weeks or months later without context when put on the spot.

    Does anyone have any ideas or best practices for turning individual lessons learned into group knowledge?



    ------------------------------
    Heidi C. Wallace, P.E., M.ASCE
    Tulsa, OK
    ------------------------------


  • 2.  RE: Converting Lessons Learned into Lessons Shared

    Posted 09-16-2025 10:42 AM

    Heidi,

    There is a body of research known as "knowledge management" that exists on storing institutional knowledge and leveraging it. There are some good books on how to implement it out there. I published a paper on it its adoption in CM firms during my PhD studies with Dr. Musibau A Shofoluwe. In practice, you see large firms implementing Knowledge management bast practices in various ways and smaller firms largely relying on more traditional elder storytelling. It's a good thing to be thinking about and a critical part of continuous improvement.



    ------------------------------
    Jesse Kamm PhD, PMP, M.ASCE
    Vice President of Engineering
    ------------------------------



  • 3.  RE: Converting Lessons Learned into Lessons Shared

    Posted 09-18-2025 06:59 PM

    Тhe real issue may not be the medium (email vs. another channel) but the content and structure of the message. If corporate emails are often ignored, personal ones go unread, or things get lost in spam, the lesson still doesn't reach the audience.

    A good solution could be something like a basic internal notes app or shared platform. The key is not just where the lesson is stored, but how it is presented:

    • A short note with situation – solution – result as the core.

    • Optionally, more detailed context available inside if someone wants to dive deeper.

    This way, the message grabs attention quickly, without overwhelming people, and those who need more information can easily access it. In the end, the focus should be on clarity and brevity to really make the lessons stick.



    ------------------------------
    Darya Stanskova M.ASCE
    Cost Estimator, Construction Engineer, Power Engineer, Project Manager
    Fort Myers FL
    ------------------------------



  • 4.  RE: Converting Lessons Learned into Lessons Shared

    Posted 09-25-2025 10:50 AM

    Dear Dara, in my view story-telling has a lot of potential, either in a community meeting like "lunch & learn" or a news letter.

    I experienced the latter in a railway operating company for sharing the experience of "near misses" in health & safety relevant situations, documented by photos. You will probably realize how important it is that people report their experience as warnings to others before really bad things happen -- and how difficult it is to provide a forum in which you can speak up frankly!

    In a small construction  company the management even held a periodic lottery among people sharing incidents (i.e. the sub-surface part of the iceberg) in the same way as you would report positively connoted observations for improvement. Not a bad idea, if you think about it.



    ------------------------------
    [J.-Martin] [Hohberg]
    [Dr.sc.techn, M.ASCE FED]
    [Sr. Consultant, IABSE e-Learning Board]
    [Bremgarten / Berne] [Switzerland]
    ------------------------------



  • 5.  RE: Converting Lessons Learned into Lessons Shared

    Posted 09-25-2025 10:50 AM

    Heidi,

    I believe that we should distinguish between, for instance,

    • information regarding changed stipulations in codes of practise, course notes from CPD events, and the like
    • feedback from debriefing meetings with clients, bad experience with joint venture partners, or similar
    • hazardous developments resulting from malpractises.

    The first category is open-access and can well be taken care of via Sharepoint, (moderated) forums or wikis. The second one is confidential and should be shared only among team leaders in sales, procurement and design; my preferred repository would be a CRM system, which you would consult when considering doing repeated business with a certain partner.

    The third category is either an item for a company-wide risk repository, to be consultant in project start meetings, or -- if very urgent and dangerous -- even for anonymous reporting extra muros to a plattform like CROSS [https://www.cross-safety.org/us/submit-a-report-us].

    So we ought to discuss also ethics and fear-less company culture, not just questions of data management and story-telling format. It's deplorable that the former PMI SIGs Risk Management and Troubled Projects are no longer active!



    ------------------------------
    [J.-Martin] [Hohberg]
    [Dr.sc.techn, aff.M. ASCE]
    [Sr. Consultant]
    [Bremgarten / Berne] [Switzerland]
    ------------------------------



  • 6.  RE: Converting Lessons Learned into Lessons Shared

    Posted 09-25-2025 10:50 AM
    Edited by Tirza Austin 09-25-2025 10:49 AM

    The primary impediment to learning from others is behavioral based on my experience. You can build the most elegant knowledge management system in the world but it will be useless without the supporting culture and behaviors. There are also cognitive biases at play. The solution needs to focus on building and fostering a culture where curiosity and questions are encouraged and rewarded. The starting point for any new project or project component needs to asking if this has been done before, how was it done, and what was learned. 



    ------------------------------
    Mitch Winkler P.E.(inactive), M.ASCE
    Houston, TX
    ------------------------------



  • 7.  RE: Converting Lessons Learned into Lessons Shared

    Posted 09-27-2025 12:24 PM

    Heidi, it's an important topic you have floated.

    First of all, sharing lessons with others – is very important. That's how we learn from one another – that's how progresses happen – that's how professional closeness develop.

    But, many learned lessons are rather trivial – some may even suffer from cognitive blunders and biases (as Mitch has pointed out) – one should keep them for oneself – as a learning process in incremental career development.

    Agreeing with others – perhaps trying to share via emails is not worth it. If persistent, the receiver may find them annoying – thinking that the sender is seeking attention. One has to keep a balance.

    Some others are worth sharing – as you have felt yourself. Finding contradictions or inapplicable standards, codes and regulations – is one familiar example.

    In cases as such, my experience tells me – that the most effective way to disseminate them – is to approach regional managers or directors, or even to corporate executives – telling them why the learned lesson is worth sharing with others within the company. If they see value – they will arrange the dissemination in one way or another. They have the leverage to allocate hours to participants – joining either in-person or on-line.

    When the learned lesson is significant and if the situation permits – one does it through publications, conference and workshop presentations. One can even begin modestly with forums like this ASCE member Forum (perhaps we are doing it, as we speak) or other professional platforms one subscribes – to assess audience response and reactions. This ushers in another learning process – augmenting one's foundation of technical, scientific and transferable skills.

    --------------------

    Dr. Dilip K Barua, PhD

    Website Links and Profile



    -------------------------------------------



  • 8.  RE: Converting Lessons Learned into Lessons Shared

    Posted 09-29-2025 12:06 PM

    Heidi the topic is so pertinent, as mentioned in other responses to your initial comments. Lessons learnt are an important tool for all of us and sharing these lessons expands our experiential base. How could we implement the necessary forum to discuss lessons learnt on projects? Is it done by discipline, project type etc?? 



    ------------------------------
    Stephen Leach C.Eng, M.ASCE
    Consultant Executive
    Luling LA
    ------------------------------



  • 9.  RE: Converting Lessons Learned into Lessons Shared

    Posted 10-18-2025 10:35 AM

    RE: Converting Lessons Learned into Lessons Shared

    I completely agree-engineers often forget lessons when asked to share them without context. This is a natural challenge, especially when the experience happened weeks or months ago.

    In my view, the solution starts before the issue is discovered. It requires:

    • Careful review and research of design standards and specifications, even those that seem irrelevant at first glance.

    • A habit of documenting lessons immediately after they occur, using a simple format like: Situation – Solution – Result

    • Having a centralized summary or internal reference that gives team members a quick idea or reminder of past lessons.

    This approach helps transform individual experiences into collective knowledge and reduces repeated mistakes across projects.

    Best regards, Bashir Ibrahim Hassan, M.ASCE Site Engineer |  Student Sakarya University – Turkey



    ------------------------------
    Bashir Ibrahim Hassan S.M.ASCE
    Civil Engineering Student
    Sakarya
    ------------------------------